From 1 or 2 Reviews to Dozens: Strategies to Multiply Your Google Reviews

Proven, practical strategies to help your business multiply its Google Reviews (without being pushy)
October 5, 2025

Google Reviews are the modern-day version of word-of-mouth.

They build trust, improve your online visibility, and directly influence whether potential customers choose you over competitors. But if you’re like many small or seasonal businesses, getting customers to actually leave those reviews can feel like pulling teeth.

That was exactly the situation Easyhike - a New Zealand-based hiking logistics company - found themselves in before they started using Yonder to collect feedback.

They had great customer satisfaction but only a trickle of Google Reviews coming through. Once they automated their feedback and review requests, that changed dramatically. Easyhike saw a 5× increase in monthly Google Reviews, while also discovering they had a perfect Net Promoter Score (NPS).

So how did they do it - and how can you replicate their results?


Here are proven, practical strategies to help your business multiply its Google Reviews without being pushy or time-consuming.

1. Make It Easy - Eliminate Friction

Most happy customers intend to leave a review but never do. Why? Because it’s inconvenient.

They have to open Google, search for your business, click through, and then find where to write the review. Every extra step is a chance for them to abandon the process.

Easyhike’s breakthrough came when they removed that friction. By using Yonder’s automated feedback flow, every customer received a short, friendly message after their trip with a direct link to leave a Google Review — no extra searching or logging in required.

Simple ways to reduce friction:

  • Include a direct review link in your follow-up emails or messages (you can generate one easily from your Google Business Profile).
  • Embed review prompts directly into feedback surveys; for instance, if a customer rates you 9 or 10/10, automatically guide them to post it on Google.
  • Optimize for mobile: Most people will be responding on their phones, so keep the process short, simple, and mobile-friendly.

When leaving a review feels effortless, participation skyrockets.

2. Ask at the Right Time

Timing can make or break your review request. Ask too early, and the experience hasn’t fully sunk in; too late, and the excitement has faded.

Easyhike nailed the timing by triggering requests automatically right after customers completed their trips, when they were still buzzing from the experience of hiking in New Zealand’s stunning landscapes. That emotional high translated into glowing, authentic reviews.

Best practices for timing:

  • Strike while the memory is fresh. Send your review request within 24–48 hours of the experience ending.
  • Avoid generic timing. A post-purchase review request might not work for service-based businesses — tailor it to when customers have truly experienced your product or service.
  • Automate it. Use your booking or CRM system to trigger review requests at the perfect time without manual follow-up.

Automation ensures consistency and removes the burden from your team... which is exactly what helped Easyhike go from the occasional review to a steady stream.

3. Use Personal, Genuine Language

Customers can tell when a review request feels robotic. A simple tweak in tone, making it conversational and appreciative, can drastically increase response rates.

Here’s a quick comparison:

"Please leave us a review on Google."
"We hope you loved your hiking adventure! Your feedback helps other travelers find us — would you mind sharing your experience on Google? It only takes a minute."

Notice the difference? The second message feels human, not transactional.

Easyhike’s messages were warm, short, and personal — written in their authentic tone. They didn’t beg for reviews; they simply reminded customers how valuable their voices were to other hikers planning their trips.

Tips for better messaging:

  • Keep it short; 3–4 lines max.
  • Use friendly, appreciative language.
  • Make it clear that the review helps others, not just your business.
  • Sign off with a real name (or your team name) for authenticity.


4. Leverage Feedback Before Asking for a Review

Not every customer is ready to leave a public review - and that’s okay. The trick is to use feedback as a natural bridge.

Yonder’s system helped Easyhike by first collecting customer feedback via NPS surveys. If a customer rated their experience highly (say 9 or 10), they were automatically prompted to share that feedback on Google.
If someone gave a lower score, Easyhike could follow up privately to resolve the issue.

This two-step approach meant:

  • Happy customers were encouraged to promote the business publicly.
  • Unhappy customers were heard privately, avoiding negative public reviews.

It’s a win-win for both reputation and customer satisfaction.

5. Follow Up (Without Being Pushy)

Even with great timing and messaging, some customers will forget to leave a review. That’s where a gentle reminder can double your results.

Easyhike’s system automatically followed up after a few days if someone hadn’t responded, but it didn’t nag. The follow-up was short, friendly, and framed as appreciation rather than obligation.

Example:

"Hey [Name], just checking in — if you haven’t had a chance to share your experience yet, we’d really appreciate it! It helps small businesses like ours grow. Here’s the link again: [Google Review Link]"

Reminders like this can increase response rates by up to 50%, especially when timed 3–5 days after the first message.

6. Celebrate and Respond to Every Review

Getting reviews is just the start, what you do with them matters. When you reply to reviews (especially on Google), you:

  • Show appreciation to the customer
  • Build trust with future readers
  • Encourage others to share their experience

Easyhike made a habit of responding to every review, whether it was a glowing 5-star message or constructive feedback. This visible gratitude strengthens relationships and encourages repeat business.
Yonder makes it easy to reply to reviews with AI-crafted review replies, written in your brand voice and ready to send at a moment's notice.

Bonus tip: Highlight standout reviews on your website or social media using Yonder's Showcase widget. Customers love seeing their words featured — and it motivates others to leave their own.


7. Turn Reviews into a Growth Loop

The biggest mindset shift Easyhike embraced was treating reviews not as a nice-to-have, but as a growth system.

Their new review volume didn’t just look good — it created tangible results:

  • Improved Google visibility (ranking higher for hiking services)
  • Increased customer trust and conversions
  • Stronger feedback insights for operational improvement

Each review became both marketing and learning material.
The result? A self-sustaining loop where happy customers attracted new ones -who, in turn, left more reviews.

To sum up, here’s what Easyhike’s experience teaches us about growing your Google Reviews organically and effectively:

  1. Reduce friction: Give customers a direct, one-click path to review you.
  2. Perfect your timing: Ask right after a positive experience.
  3. Make it personal: Use authentic, friendly language.
  4. Leverage feedback first: Turn happy customers into public promoters.
  5. Follow up thoughtfully: Gentle reminders go a long way.
  6. Engage and respond: Every review is an opportunity to build trust.
  7. Automate the process: Let technology handle the follow-up so your team can focus on what matters — great customer experiences.

Easyhike’s journey proves that review growth doesn’t happen by luck.

It’s the result of smart systems and customer-first thinking. By combining Yonder's AI with authentic communication, they went from one or two reviews a month to a steady flow of dozens, all while deepening their customer relationships.

If you want to boost your visibility, reputation, and trust online, start by making it effortless for your happiest customers to share their stories. Because when you make leaving a review easy — and meaningful — the results will speak for themselves.

Get in touch

Thank you! We'll be in touch as soon as we can, within the next working day.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Can we help?
We're here to help you achieve your goals, whatever they might be. Whether you want to roll out Yonder today or you want to chat about what’s next in tourism tech, reach out to our friendly team for a chat.

Recent posts